|
|
How Many Grafts Will Make Me Happy?
What Drs. Rassman and Bernstein
recommend
First Follicular Unit Transplantation Session
Total Number of Follicular Units Suggested
for a Complete Restoration One of the most frequent questions asked by potential hair transplant
patients is: "How many grafts will I need?" The answer should:
- Take realistic expectations into consideration
- Reflect the patient's degree of hair loss, donor supply, and hair
characteristics
- Be consistent with a long-term Master Plan to address future hair
loss
- Address the number of potential procedures and time commitment required
- Consider the short and total long-term cost for the patient
An individual's goals must be realistic. For example, if a person has
significant balding (i.e., a Norwood Class 6 or 7 pattern) and fine hair,
then he should not expect a full head of transplanted hair. If he does,
dissatisfaction will be inevitable. With at least 65-75% of hair lost
(the typical loss in Class 6 and 7 patients), a thin head of hair is a
realistic and achievable goal. Although a thin head of hair can dramatically
improve patient's appearance, if he were to attempt to achieve his original
density, he would run out of donor hair before the process could be completed
and an unnatural appearance would result.
Working within reasonable expectations, the total number of grafts required
for any one patient will depend upon hair and skin color, donor density,
scalp laxity the thickness of each hair shaft, the number of hairs in
each graft, and the character of the hair itself. The physician must consider
these factors and the expectations of the patient in order to calculate
the amount of work required. Even when these considerations are combined
with the expectations of the patient, the amount of work required to make
a person satisfied is sometimes difficult to predict.
Naivet of the physician, even in those who specialize in hair transplantation,
seems to be more common than many care to admit. The failure of the physician
to establish realistic expectations often leads to an unhappy patient.
This can only be prevented by providing a clear explanation of the hair
restoration process, and specifically defining the benefits that the patient
may expect to achieve. Hair Color and Skin Color Contrast
Hair color and its contrast to skin color is one of the most significant
factors that dictate the amount of work required for hair restoration.
The lower the contrast, the fewer grafts are required. Blonde hair against
fair skin and dark hair against dark skin are two examples of hair combinations
that produce excellent results with less work on the part of the physician
(and less cost for the patient). Dark hair against pale skin often requires
the most hair in the restoration process. Of course, a patient can simply
lighten his hair to make the restoration look more full. One of the (few)
benefits of aging is that it will accomplish reduced contrast between
hair and skin all by itself. Hair Character
Hair character is the second most important factor in determining the
amount of hair restoration work needed. Curly or wavy hair produces a
full appearance more easily than straight hair. African American hair
in particular curls so that a single hair shaft covers more scalp with
less hair length than straight hair. Strong, naturally curly hair that
holds its shape tends to produce fuller results more easily than thin
straight hair that falls flat against the scalp. Hair Bulk
Hair bulk, or hair shaft diameter, contributes greatly to the visual impact
of hair. Coarse hair has greater bulk and requires fewer hair follicles
per square inch than fine hair to produce the same effect. Coarse hair
usually grows naturally in smaller groups (follicular units) than fine
hair and should be transplanted that way for the most natural results.
Hair Density
In the majority of patients who are candidates for a hair transplant,
hair density (the number of hairs per cm2) varies from about 150 hairs/cm2
to over 300 hairs/cm2, with the average of about 200 hair/cm2. However,
as previously mentioned, hair in the human scalp does not grow as single
hairs, but in groups of 1-4 hairs. Interestingly, these naturally occurring
groups (called follicular units (FU)) have a relatively constant density
in the scalp of 100 FU/cm2. This means that the average follicular unit
will contain from 2.0 hairs. Those patients who average 1.5 hairs per
follicular unit will have a naturally thin appearance and therefore a
thinner appearing transplant. Those patients who average 3.0 hairs per
follicular unit (300/hairs per cm2) will have a fuller looking transplant.
How Many Grafts Will
Make Me Happy?
When patients ask how many grafts it will take to make them happy, what
they are really saying is, "give me back what I lost and I'll be
happy." When this is the case, what the bald man really wants is
unrealistic; therefore, one must address how much work needs to be done
to make the patient satisfied. Satisfaction should be addressed in relative
terms to make this problem understandable.
A man who is accustomed to his balding will be easier to please, and will
accept a less full appearance than a young man who is starting to lose
his hair and who remembers the days when he looked in the mirror and saw
the vibrant, full hair of a teenager. The young patient wants his adolescent
hairline and density back and will often be satisfied with nothing less.
Since surgery is permanent, the hair-restoring surgeon must plan a hairline
that will be appropriate for the patient's entire life and he must transplant
a density that is consistent with long-term donor reserves. Because of
these factors, some young patients are not good candidates for surgery.
The older patient with significant hair loss, on the other hand, will
often be ecstatic with his mature hairline restored and a modest amount
of natural-looking hair covering his head for the first time in years.
For the majority of patients between these two extremes, the physician's
careful guidance will help the patient understand what goals can realistically
be achieved and whether hair restoration will be worthwhile.
With an understanding of human nature, hair dynamics, and practical issues,
we have concluded that it is not always wise to recommend a specific number
of grafts as though this number is an absolute amount. Instead, we often
recommend transplant sessions of the greatest number of grafts that can
be reasonably and safely moved within the confines of four important constraints
listed below.
- The patient's goals
- The projected pattern of hair loss in a worst-case scenario, as determined
by heredity, age and physical examination
- The amount of hair in the permanent zone (donor area) that can be
safely transplanted (this is related to a number of physical factors
including donor density and scalp laxity and should be assessed by the
doctor at the time of consultation)
- Economic and time constraints of the patient
The Physician's goal is to help the patient understand how close he or
she can come to meeting personal needs and expectations, how much the
hair restoration will cost, and how many sessions it is likely to require.
Do not start the hair restoration process unless you understand what it
will take to finish it. With proper planning, satisfaction is easy to
achieve.
Keep in mind that the transplantable hair numbers generally reflect an
average amount of total hair that can be moved and applied to one's hair
loss. This movable hair can be transplanted in one or multiple sessions
depending on the four factors above and your doctor's skill and experience.
For example, if procedures are limited to only 100 grafts each, then patients
will be committed to an extended number of surgical sessions. Possibly
not obvious at the onset, such extended treatment sessions often end with
the patient losing interest. Financial or personal reasons may also cause
the patient to fail to complete the treatment course. Just as important,
multiple, small procedures move hair inefficiently and waste precious
donor supply.
The impact of the transplant depends both upon the distribution of grafts
as the absolute number used. Nonetheless, it is still useful for the patient
anticipating surgery to have a general idea of the numbers required, both
for the initial procedure and for subsequent sessions.
What Drs. Rassman and Bernstein recommend
Although there is significant variation from person to person, the average
number of follicular units that we generally transplant in the first session
for specific Norwood classifications is listed below. We first presented
these numbers in our landmark 1995 publication "Follicular Transplantation."
The recommend numbers have changed little over the years, except that
with the implementation of stereomicroscopic dissection, we rarely need
to transplant more than 2400 grafts in a single session. All "units"
or "grafts" in this discussion refer to follicular units, not
minigrafts or micrografts. First Follicular Unit Transplantation
Session Norwood Class Follicular Units Total Units With Crown
3 800-1000+ ---
3 Vertex 800-1000+ 1100-1300+
3A 1300-1600+ ---
4 1100-1400+ 1500-1800+
4A 1700-2100+ ---
5 1500-1800+ 1900-2400+
5A 2000-2400+ ---
6 2000-2400+ 2400+
7 2000-2400+ ---
In general, the higher the donor density, the greater the number of
hairs each follicular unit will contain. With low donor density, little
scalp laxity or poor hair characteristics, these targets may not be achievable.
We generally do not recommend hair restoration surgery for Class 3 patients
unless the hair loss is cosmetically very bothersome, the hair loss pattern
seems stable, and the patient has excellent donor reserves. Often these
patients have special circumstances, such as career demands, which require
transplantation at an early stage. Medications are the best initial treatment,
especially with early Class 3 patients.
The number of grafts required to complete the hair transplant process
for a given Norwood Class may vary significantly from individual to individual.
Nevertheless, it is helpful for someone anticipating surgery to have an
idea of the number of follicular units that a typical individual would
need for a complete restoration, both with and without crown coverage.
(This data was published in Follicular Transplantation: Patient Evaluation
and Surgical Planning. Dermatologic Surgery 1997.) Total Number of Follicular Units Suggested
for a Complete Restoration Norwood Class Follicular Units Total Units With Crown
3 900-1500 ---
3 Vertex 900-1500 1300-2000
3A 1400-2200 ---
4 1200-2000 1700-3000
4A 1800-3600 ---
5 1700-3000 2100-4000
5A 2000-4400 ---
6 2200-4600 3000-5600
7 2200-4800 4000-6600
A satisfactory restoration does not necessarily mean that complete coverage
of the entire bald area has been achieved. Finite donor supplies often
limit what can be accomplished, |
|
Hair Loss information on this site has been
contributed by hair loss specialists and surgeons who have
years of experience in the field of hair loss.
|
|